How We Pick: Locals Only Rankings

Every ranked list in Locals Only is scored the same way, by us, and no company can pay for a position. This page explains the scoring so you can judge it.

What we score

Each company on a list gets a score from six criteria. The first two come from public data. The other four we check ourselves.

Criterion Weight How it's scored
Google rating 20% A 5.0 scores full marks. A 4.0 scores zero. Everything between is scaled.
Review volume 20% Scaled against the most-reviewed company in the category, flattened so a company with 4,000 reviews doesn't bury one with 400.
Years operating locally 20% Ten or more years in Northeast Florida scores full marks. Under two years scores one point. If a company doesn't publish its founding date, it gets a provisional five until we confirm it with state records.
Licensing and insurance 20% Full marks if the Florida license is verified and the company is insured. Half if the company states it's licensed but doesn't publish the number. Zero if we can't confirm it.
Service area 10% Full marks for all four counties (Duval, St. Johns, Clay, Nassau). Seven for three. Half for two. Two points for one.
Responsiveness 10% We call or submit a form. A reply within one business day scores full marks. Within three days, half. No reply, zero.

The ranking is the total. Ties go to the company with more verified reviews.

First editions. When a list publishes for the first time, responsiveness hasn't been measured yet. On those lists the other five criteria are weighted up to fill the gap (rating and volume at 25% each), and responsiveness is added at the first re-rank. Each list says which edition it is at the top.

What we don't score

  • Our own experience as a customer. If we've hired a company, we say so in the entry and it gets no extra credit.
  • Advertising anywhere, including with us.
  • Social media followers.
  • Awards from pay-to-play "best of" programs.

What sponsors can buy

Sponsors can buy a labeled spotlight article, a featured card next to a list, or an expanded entry with photos and links on a spot they already earned. Every one of those is marked "Sponsored" or "Featured partner" where it appears.

Sponsors cannot buy a position on a ranked list, inclusion on a list, or a change to their score. A company can be a sponsor and fall off a list in the same month. The agreement says so.

Disclosure

Jax Humor's owner also runs Narsil Creative, a marketing agency. Any company that is a Narsil client, or has any other business connection to us, is disclosed in its entry. We don't publish lists of marketing or SEO agencies for that reason.

How often lists change

  • Full re-rank, twice a year. Every company is rescored, new candidates are added, and companies that closed or slipped come off. Each category refreshes about six weeks before its busy season.
  • Status check, every quarter. We confirm each listed company is open and that its phone, hours, and website still work. No re-ranking.
  • Anytime. A closure, a reader correction, or a major new opening gets fixed when we learn about it.

The "Updated" date on each list changes only when the content changes. A short note under it says what changed.

Tell us who we missed

Know a company that belongs on a list, or one that shouldn't be there anymore? Email jaxhumor@gmail.com with the company name and why. Owners can nominate their own business. It gets scored like everyone else.